Melissa McCarthy Talks About Having “Real” Moments With Puppets in ‘The Happytime Murders’ [Set Visit Interview]

Last October, I visited the set of Brian Henson‘s The Happytime Murders and was shocked and appalled by the puppet naughtiness. Today, I present to you our roundtable interview with human star Melissa McCarthy talked about having “real” moments with puppet characters, working with the Henson Company, wanting to make the movie after reading two pages, navigating a set built for puppets, the social message of the film, hilarious puppet bloopers, and being directed from a guy in a garbage can.

How surreal of an acting challenge is it to work with the puppets?

What’s crazy is that I thought it was gonna be this whole tricky thing. I thought, “Okay, I guess it will be kinda like with a tennis ball, just ‘cause there’s no eye contact and they’re not looking at you.” What happened about 15 minutes in was that I bumped into Phil and I was like, “Oh, I’m sorry, Phil.” And then, I was like, “Oh, okay, I’m nuts!” We’ve had emotional scenes. It’s also ‘cause there’s a crazy thing happening with what a good and incredibly grounded actor Bill Barretta is. They’re not putting wackiness on top of a puppet. It’s a really good, solid character. Within seconds, it goes away in your head and you’re having these lovely scenes, or you’re having fights. I’m weirdly constantly apologizing to Phil. Bill is laying on the ground and I don’t say a word to him, but I’m like, “Phil, I’m sorry.” It’s a whole different thing than anything I could have expected. They’re just so good that they inhabit these puppets and they become incredibly real, immediately.

Is that what drew you to this, or was it the social undercurrent of it?

It was the social undercurrent, for sure. I thought it was really, really smart. I thought it was saying something without preaching about it, which is always the best way to get your point across. And then, I just thought, “I’ve never seen that.” I’ve never seen this kind of world. And to get to do anything with the Hensons and the dynasty that comes with that. If you’re gonna see how it works, my god, this is the group to do it with. It’s amazing! The machine of how it’s done and who comes in, sometimes there’s four people in one puppet, but the puppet is the most natural thing. There are four humans behind it, but that immediately goes away. It’s getting to work with the very best of the best that do it, and it’s been pretty dreamy. It’s certainly surreal. The Clodhoppers come out and I have so many contraband pictures. I’m constantly like, “Oh, my god, that’s crazy!” I’d never seen one of those in action before. It’s really crazy! It’s just pure imagination.

What can you tell us about your character’s relationship with Phil?

Phil and Edwards, my character, came up together. I always thought they were probably in the Academy together and they were partners, and Phil was the first puppet police officer. They were really, really best friends. They had that kind of partnership where you become each other’s confidante and best friend. That’s the person you check in with and who’s your touchstone. And then, when the incident occurred and Phil took a puppet’s life, we were both so damaged by it. It’s so weird to talk about, but there are heartbreaking scenes from Phil. It’s a challenging relationship now ‘cause we’re both damaged goods, which is what I thought was so interesting. One event can shatter a relationship and shatter lives. I have a terrible addiction to sugar, which is like heroin for puppets. It’s ruining my life and I blame him for it, but he saved my life by putting a puppet liver in me. It’s very dark and very complicated, and at the same time, we have all that stuff built in where you know these people have been together for so long. Even when we fight, you can only fight that way with people that you know and love. It’s brotherly-sisterly love, and they’re best friends. They’re really interesting characters, and there are dark areas and goofy areas. It’s the perfect thing I love, where you touch on a lot of different things.

Is it true that maple syrup gets a bad rap in this movie?

Yes and no. It really gets highlighted. I open my refrigerator and it’s lined with maple syrup. That’s what I have in my flask, at all times. It’s a love letter and also a cautionary tale, mainly for Canadians.

Ben Falcone said that you did a pass on the script. Was that to add your sense of humor to it?

It was just to flush out what I wanted to do with Edwards, once I really started to think about what the damage is, how she’s broken and how she’s different. The script was so good that my pass was really just clarifying what I wanted to say. Ben always makes fun of me. He’s like, “You spend eight million years killing yourself over each line, and you’re gonna say something different on set. I don’t know why you bother.”

By page 2, when I read this – and I’m not exaggerating – Ben was outside and I walked out and was like, “I think I’m in.” He was like, “You’ve been gone 13 seconds. What do you mean?” I was like, “I know, but there’s a big street scene of gritty L.A. and they’re playing ‘I’m Your Puppet.’” He was like, “Why don’t you go read it?” And then, I came back out on page 4 and was like, “I’m just saying, I really think I’m already in.” I never say that. I wait until the very end and I think about it, but I had the strangest reaction to it. We all grew up with puppets, and when they’re inhabited in such a realistic way, there’s the little voice in the back of your head that goes, “I knew it! I knew they were real!” It’s everything you thought of, as a kid. They just talked to me.

Do they retain their magic, even after doing this?

What’s really fun is if Bill or one of the puppeteers gets a cramp, but they still have the puppet on, the puppet is suddenly having some kind of a fit. Also, when they talk to camera, it gets me, every time. Bill makes Phil glide out of a scene, but when everything works, it’s crazy. There’s a scene when a puppet is holding me hostage, but I buy it, 100%. And the puppet is this big and in a white pantsuit, for god’s sake. She’s very chic. She’s a sociopath, but she’s very chic.

Just how adult is this film?

It’s definitely a grown-up movie. My kids are like, “We can’t wait to see this!” And I’m like, “I can’t wait to show you, when you’re 40! It will be so wonderful, when you’re 110 and you can see this!” I think it’s part of the fun of it. Somebody was saying that there’s always that thing, when you watch something from The Muppets, one of the movies, or Sesame Street, there’s always that inkling of, when the lights go off, somebody says cut, and they walk out the back door, do they go into the real world and have a life? This is really seeing behind the curtain. When the lights are off and they’re not having to perform for people, you see the real grind of their lives, and there’s something really cool about it. There’s a weird, edgy coolness, and it’s really funny. It manages to take all those things and shove them together, and weirdly the puppet thing dissolves, but it’s right there. That’s a terrible description of what it is. You don’t not see that they’re puppets, but you immediately think that they’re living, breathing and real. It’s crazy!

What’s it like to have to act around them?

It’s such a technical thing. There are all these squares on the floor and it’s why all of the sets are built up. The puppeteers stand on the floor and their optimum way to operate is if they’re standing with straight arms, so all of these squares come out. As you’re walking, you have a two-foot margin to stay on your path and there are all these people in crazy green suits that look like a cult. The technical aspect of it is so crazy. All the puppeteers doing this have been with Brian and the Hensons for so long. Even though there’s no floor and I don’t want to fall down, they’re such good actors and they’re so good at what they do that that all goes away. It’s pretty remarkable, I have to say.

How much do you improvise with the puppets?

A lot. They’re crazy! They’re crazy funny! All of them improvise. You can throw anything at them. Every time Drew [Massey], who plays several things in this, did a take, it was completely different, which both delighted and irritated me. I was like, “Is this written down?! I really work on this, and I think you might just be saying stuff, off the top of your head.” And each one was super specific, really funny and completely different. I was like, “I just wanna see where it’s written. We’re on your eighth take, and it keeps getting better and funnier. Now, I’m just jealous.” He was like, “I’m just saying stuff. Is that okay?” You can throw anything at them. That’s what they do. You can go anywhere with them, and they’ll be two steps ahead of them, for sure.

Can you tell us about Bill Barretta?

Bill Barretta is a dreamboat. He’s so good. I can’t imagine anybody else — he’ll talk about it, but this is his grandfather Phil. He’s taken a lot. It’s such a personal dreamy character at the heart of it, and he’s just — how he walks him, when he’s upset. When Phil’s upset, which doesn’t make any sense, because his face can barely move, his eyes can barely move, but when Phil is upset, everybody feels it. That’s Bill Barretta being really kind of this weird wizard at what he does. I mean, there’s really no reason you get all this emotion and humor. You know when he’s hiding something, and you know when he’s stalling and when he’s angry, but I’m like, but nothing’s changed! How do you do it? It’s a great magic trick. He’s really smart, and we talk about the script all the time and we’re always making adjustments. He has such a good feel for it. If something’s not right, I feel like Phil and I always kind of sit with it for a few minutes and we both are really in sync, which is a delight. I mean, you want that with your co-stars, but he’s just something else. I was like, can you do something else without a puppet? I just want to put him in everything, puppet or no puppet.